Welcome to Pizza Pie

“ We ordered few pizzas and salad. Cucumbers feta salad was only cucumber and little feta ) kinda expensive for just cucumber. Not good at all. Pizzas was good but cold( maybe they prebake an advance) My tai cocktail was $19 i did not finish it it’s was ice cream inside (ice creamy piece was there) and drink doesn’t look clean and it was so sweet too much. I took a wine and wine glass wasn’t clean or clear it was dry drops from water visible. I asked for new and got the same . Server was very nice. ”

“ I love Pizza Pie! I was so excited when they opened because it's a two minute walk from home but, more importantly, their pizzas are great, the service is friendly, and both indoor/outdoor seating is nice. Both times I've dined in, there seemed to be just one person working the front - meaning they were working the bar, seating guests, taking orders, serving the food, etc. - but they were friendly and efficient. I've tried five different kinds of pizza and they've all been solid - but I keep going back to the Margherita because it's simple and delicious. I'm sure there are bound to be NYers who'll correct me and say, "That ain't no pizza!" but speaking as an average American pizza consumer, the pizzas are good! The one thing I'll say is one pizza probably won't cut it if you've got a healthy appetite. Because all their pies are thin, I can easily eat two/force down a third. Pizza Pie is definitely worth a visit - it's in my rotation when family/friends are in town! ”

“ Fairly priced food where other Italian restaurants are at over $30 a plate. Nice staff and we sat right away for dinner. Proportions are mostly fair. They look small on these larger plates. Happy hour is 5 to 7:00 Monday through Friday makes the drinks more reasonable. The spaghetti sauce is not very creamy and has lots of tomato chunks. The Alfredo and pink sauce are creamy and rich. They also have deep fried Oreos so that's a bonus. ”

“ Our family loved this place. We ordered 2 different pizzas and the Hawaiian burger (for the non pizza lover). All of the food was delicious. I highly recommend the Italian sausage mushroom pie. ”

“ This is a really nice establishment but they weren't doing dine in for lunch. We got two pizzas and some truffle fries. The pizzas didn't have enough sauce or cheese for my liking. This could just be their style but the pizzas seemed really bare and not all that flavorful. The fries were really good though. We each had a cocktail while waiting and their bar is top notch. ”

“ Entrance was a bit off to the side from the sign, but very nice space. Ordered mozzarella sticks and the sausage pizza and it’s absolutely fantastic given there isn’t a good pizza joint nearby. Can’t really make your own pizza, but they have a solid amount of speciality pizzas to cover every craving. ”

“ Gotta love when one bad restaurant leads you to a good one. So glad we stumbled upon this place. It’s newer, but the service was excellent and the food came out extremely fast. We had the burrata salad, which was delicious, margherita pizza, and the house made bolognese. Of all the dishes we had, the pizza was likely my favorite. Although, I did like the burrata cheese on the salad. The pizza is thin crust, but it has great flavor. The bolognese was a great portion and good as well. I would recommend this place and will definitely be back in the future. ”

“ We ordered a Hawaiian pizza and substituted ham for chicken. Here's what we got. Where'd the pepperoni and jalapeño come from? That's not supposed to be on a Hawaiian pizza. Fortunately I liked the mess up. The reviews are mostly accurate. The pizza is good but they'll screw up your order if you get it to go. ”